Home > Baseball > Mlb Ejections For Managers

Mlb Ejections For Managers

January 26th, 2008

Why do MLB managers bother arguing calls with umpires?

It seems to happen quite often. Is it simply for team moral? Has a call ever been overturned because of a complaint? All is seems to do is lead to the eventual ejection. Is it all for the enjoyment of the fans or is there really a point to it?

To those who say managers who argue sometimes “win”: nope. The manager who disputes a call and politely comes out and asks what the umpire saw is more likely to get the umpire to ask his partners for help, such as on whether a batted ball hit the batter in the box, a pitch hit the batter, a tag was made, a catch was made, or a ball was fair when leaving the field of play in flight.

The manager who acts like an idiot and screams and yells that the umpire was wrong will get nothing. So, too, will the manager who questions balls and strikes.

Keep in mind that when an umpire does ask his partners for help, only he can change the call.

Some managers and coaches argue to get their players motivated. Some argue because they actually don’t want to be at the game that particular day and need an excuse to split. Others will pick up an argument to keep a player in the game.

Any manager or coach who thinks arguing is going to give him any edge on the next close play is sadly mistaken. Only the worst of the worst umpires (say recreational league umpires) would ever let that happen.

And, of course, some managers and coaches argue because they think it’s their job to be jerks. These are the ones who tend to be thrown out with great frequency.

TSN Top 10 Manager Ejections 2011 Edition


High Heat Baseball 2003


High Heat Baseball 2003


$33.45


High Heat, Major League Baseball 2003 (CD-ROM)…


Comments are closed.